
So maybe you just bought an Ipod and want to buy music for it. For those of you considering switching from buying cd’s or downloading from Kazaa to get your music from Itunes, this article is for you. You might think that the title is a bit harsh, but let us take the definition of evil. Merriam-Webster defines it as: “inferior, offensive, and disagreeable.” Let me now explain why this is accurate. First of all, Itunes is terrible for artists. Itunes charges 99 cents per song, which by the way, is likely to be raised very soon. Of every song sold, Itunes gets 35% and the record companies get 65%. This amounts to about 8 to 14 cents per song to the artist. So for 1000 songs sold, the artist gets a whopping 80 bucks! So really, as you can see, when people complain about huge losses in music profits do to illegal file sharing, they really mean losses to the record companies, and even those losses are debatable. If this doesn’t bother you, then don’t worry, there is plenty more to dislike.
Some might be partial to the whole Itunes experience, personally I dislike it and find it overly simple for the amount of cpu and ram it uses. The real problem however, is when you download a song online, you are buying it in AAC format, Apple’s version of MP3 . When apple calls it a “lossless” codec what they really mean is that you lose. Unlike a CD, the music from Itunes is compressed and its quality is lowered. If you purchase a CD, you can choose to rip the music at any quality level using any codec. This means if you don’t have an Ipod, then you can rip music in a format you can actually play on another MP3 player. Other examples of codecs besides AAC are MP3, OGG, WMA, FLAC and MAC. All of these are used for a variety of reasons, many claim one sounds better than another and so on, but the nice thing with a CD is you have options, not so with Itunes.
So far, not terrible, I admit. Trust me when I say I saved the best for last. Itunes couldn’t convince the record companies to sell music without a catch, that catch is known as DRM. DRM stands for digital rights management. Basically it means that whenever you try to do anything with “your” music that Apple or the record companies don’t like, they can beat you senseless with a large stick. DRM means that you really don’t own your music, you are using it with permission for a fee. With a DRM protected song, Itunes decides what, who, when, and how many times, a song can be played. Itunes limits how many times you can burn a song to cd and when you want to move music to another computer you have to bother with “authorizing” it to play your songs, which means you can’t have all the computers in your house have copies of your music. It also prevents AAC music from being played on a non-Apple device; basically every other mp3 player on the market. I am not alone in my hatred for this system, in fact, there are several projects out there which attempt to hack or remove this protection. I wouldn’t recommend using this if you have already bought music online since the last time Apple released an Itunes update it rendered any DRM songs that were hacked, unplayable.
You might be comfortable with this kind of purchase but I like to think that when I purchase music I am free to exercise my fair-use rights. Here is my recommendation, don’t use Itunes. If you must download music, try the service I recommended last time called Allofmp3.com. Not only does it not protect music like Itunes, but you can choose any quality and codec to download the music, and it costs about 10 cents a song. The best choice however is still to buy the CD. Try going to Amazon.com and purchasing a “used” cd. I often find many in this category selling for 5 dollars and they arrive in the shrink wrap. You’ll appreciate buying cd’s when a year from now your laptop/Ipod breaks and you lose all your music.
Gadget of the Week
First a quick update from last weeks Gadget. Last week I mentioned that the legality of Allofmp3.com was in question. This week I am slightly less concerned since a district attorney in Russia has claimed it cannot be prosecuted with their current laws, which only prohibit the distribution of physical cd’s. Basically this means expect Allofmp3.com to remain online for 3-5 years, the time it takes Russia to update its copyright laws.
Many of you have Ipods, that is certainly not a new gadget, but I bet you haven’t given thought to what headphones you use; but you should. Besides the electronics used in an MP3 player, the headphones are the next most important part for sound quality. The problem with the included Ipod headphones is that they are made to be as cheap as possible, so the sound quality is bad and they can be very uncomfortable after extended use. So what options are available? Depends how much money you’re willing to spend. First, Sony has been offering very good in-ear buds which can cost anywhere from 25 to 50 dollars. Sony has even started selling a white version to match the o-so-fashion cautious users. The next step up is really more of a jump with prices going from 100 to 400 dollars. The best headphones in this category are those from Etymotic and Shure. These two companies make the headphones professional musicians use on stage at live concerts. I personally own the Shure E3C headphones, a great set with sound reproduction like nothing else. If you are familiar with these types you would know that they are “in-ear” headphones. That is, they are meant to be worn inside the entrance to the ear canal. This has several advantages. First, it offers natural noise reduction, great for airplanes and public areas, and secondly, the material used is often a very soft rubber, allowing hours of use without any discomfort. For the common user, I recommend the Sony Fontopia headphones, for audiophiles, the Shure E2c’s.
Posted in Uncategorized